Help stop shark cruelty on World Oceans Day

Animals Australia

Animals Australia team

Last updated 8 June 2011

June 8th is World Oceans Day, a day to celebrate the natural
wonders of the earth’s vast underwater world. These oceans are the place
where life on earth originated and still today it is home to an
incredibly diverse web of life.

But this web is under immense pressure
from human activities such as pollution and overfishing. Sharks are at
the top of this web, but they are now balancing on the edge of
extinction due to the enormous demand for a bowl of soup — shark fin

Read our special World Oceans Day interview with shark defender and former world record holding free diver, Fred Buyle below and then take action to save our sharks.

Diving with sharks


Name: Fred Buyle
Born: 1972, Belgium
Free diving career: started free diving when he was 8 in the Mediterranean Sea, held 3 world records and was the 8th person to break through the 100m mythical barrier on one breath of air
Occupation: underwater photographer, shark conservationist, free diving instructor

Fred, how did your passion for sharks develop?
Ever since I was a kid I liked the shape of sharks. But I was also fascinated by them because I always heard people say that sharks are dangerous. You know, I grew up with the Jaws movies and people from my generation have what I call the ‘Jaws syndrome’. Because of these movies we think of sharks as killing machines designed to shred people to pieces. But I wanted to see with my own eyes what these creatures are like.

The first time I was in the water with sharks was in Indonesia when I was 13. They were reef sharks and of course my initial reaction was “wow they’re dangerous, I might get bitten", but after a little while I realised that they were just swimming around and not really interested in me. I have since been nose to nose with great white sharks and literally bumped into big tiger sharks and I discovered that instead of being aggressive, they are actually very shy animals. This made me understand that the image we have of them is false.

You say that they are not aggressive. So what is normally the cause of a shark attack?
First of all I don’t see it as ‘attacks’ as this implies deliberate aggression. Shark accidents normally happen to surfers or swimmers because they float on the surface and have no idea what’s going on under the water. Therefore they have no interaction with the shark that might be observing them, which is an indication to the shark that the level of threat is low and it’s safe to check ‘it’ — a potential feed — out from closer by. This normally involves a bite.

See, a shark will never take any risk to get food. They circle around a potential prey to gage it, to see how it reacts, if it’s dangerous for him or not. If there is no response the shark thinks that it is safe. As a diver you establish contact with the shark. You let the shark know that you’ve seen it. And if you show no sign of fear the shark will understand that you’re not a potential prey. Even a 5 meter great white will simply swim away.



With your passion for sharks, the shark finning business must really upset you.

The shark finning industry is very cruel and damaging. It only occurs
because some people have the false idea that shark fins are good for
them and because it’s a traditional Asian dish. Most disturbing about
shark finning is that the fishermen cut off the fins of the sharks
whilst they are alive and dump its body back in the ocean. Without her
fins, the injured shark is unable to swim and therefore unable to
circulate water through her gills. She sinks to the ocean floor to
either slowly suffocate or be eaten alive.

How many sharks are killed for their fins?
is difficult to give an accurate figure but it will be at least one
hundred million every year and estimates go as high as four hundred
million each year. The result is that populations of shark species have
declined enormously all around the world. I’ve seen a dramatic change
during my free diving career. It has become more difficult to find
sharks simply because there are a lot less around than 20 years ago.

WARNING: some scenes in this video may be distressing.

And this has a big impact on the health of our oceans, right?

yes, the impact on the whole ocean eco system is enormous. If sharks,
as apex predators, disappear, it disrupts the whole natural balance. For
example in the East Pacific the hammerheads are disappearing.
Hammerheads usually feed on squid, and squid on their turn eat small
fish and larvae of fish. So with the squid population increasing due to a
lack of sharks the number of smaller fish is dropping sharply and the
whole system is at risk.

In your eyes, what is the solution?
most important thing is to stop the demand. The market is mostly in
China, Hong Kong and Taiwan, so that’s where the education needs to be
done primarily. People need to be informed of the enormous cruelty and
damage this industry is causing. That is the only way we can save the
sharks. It is impossible to regulate the industry because most shark
finning happens illegally and in international waters where there are no

Some countries are banning shark fishing and finning in their
territorial waters, but there will always be poachers. Other countries,
and states in America, are making it illegal to sell shark fins, which
is a very positive step.

You are also very concerned about the damage caused by shark nets. As a diver, what have you seen?
nets in Australia and other countries are installed to protect swimmers
and surfers. Many animals get caught in the nets and die a slow death,
but most of these animals are completely harmless. On studying the nets,
it becomes clear that most of the animals actually get caught whilst
they are trying to find a way out of the netted area. This means that
they managed to get through in the first place, which shows that the
nets are completely ineffective and the animals die for no reason. We
have to accept that the waters are these animals’ natural habitat, it’s
their territory not ours. It disturbs me deeply that we make the animals
suffer again, needlessly.

Surfers are the most frequent victim
of a shark incident, but 95% of surfers don’t want shark nets as they
know the damaging effects that they have. Most surfers really care about
the environment and love the ocean with everything in it. They know
that they’re taking a risk, but they also know that most shark species
are endangered and don’t want to see them get hurt.


So how are you trying to help the sharks?

my work I try to show people the true face of sharks. I hope that this
helps to debunk the myth that they are dangerous animals. My photography
and diving trips where William Winram and
I take people into the water with sharks are aimed to open up this
otherwise so invisible world to a broad audience to create awareness and
make people want to save sharks from the crisis that they are currently

Free diving is perfect for this because you can be part of
the underwater world in a completely natural way. Without the noise of
scuba gear (due to breathing and air bubbles) you don’t disturb the
animals and they don’t try to get away from you — in fact they even
start to approach you out of curiosity — so you can observe their
behaviour from closer by and for a longer period of time.


Do you feel that you are making progress?
we are seeing things change slowly in a positive way. The film
producers, camera men, journalists etc. that we are taking diving with
sharks are becoming more interested in portraying sharks in a different
light. They start to see a different potential for their work and with
environmental issues now becoming more important, media portrayal of
sharks is changing. This makes them a messenger for the conservation

This is creating a tangible shift in attitudes which we
notice when we give presentations. When presenting to younger people,
they will often not think of sharks as being dangerous, but instead as
animals that need protection because they have learned that sharks are
being slaughtered for their fins and are becoming endangered.

So what can people do to help?
most important thing is for people to learn about sharks. Everybody
should go to see them in the water so they will understand these animals
better and will be keener to protect them because, I know for sure,
they will like them. Also, unfortunately shark fin soup is still widely
available in Chinese restaurants in Australia, so people should make
sure never to order this dish.

If you want to learn more about
Fred’s work, please visit his website.

You can help!

Shark fishing in Australia is
still legal and while there are laws regarding the finning of live
sharks, they are difficult to police. The only effective way to protect
sharks is to ban the sale of shark fins. You can help sharks by urging
Environment Minister Greg Hunt to ban the sale of shark fins in
Australia. Please send Minister Hunt a message

Are you inspired by Fred’s story? Simple, every-day choices can have a dramatic impact on our precious oceans and the life they contain. Please share your comments below and let others know how you plan to help save our amazing marine animals!